Sam Knapper
Professors Paulo and Adriana Ribeiro
IDIS 150 B
26 January 2010
My Approach and Calling
As Christians live for God, the Lord will start to transform their lives in a way that will further His kingdom. John Calvin explained that this transformation can only be possible through “a double grace” that comes solely from God (Plantinga 92). The Lord justifies the Christian by removing his guilt, and then the Lord continually transforms His vessel into something more and more like Himself through the process of sanctification. The transformation is not easy, and most Christians can vouch for that. The new believers may not have experienced the true depth of the transformation yet. After they have given their all to the Lord, He begins to set in motion a process that cannot be reversed.
Everything that will happen to the new believer after his conversion is designed to transform him into something that God desires him to be. As I reflect on my Developing the Christian Mind class, I realize that God placed me in this class to draw me closer to Him. God has continuously transformed me ever since I had given my life to Him. This class was designed to teach more about God and how I am supposed to approach His creation. Through Cornelius Plantinga’s Engaging God’s World and various works of C. S. Lewis, God intended this class to improve my relationship with Him.
As we read and discussed a wide array of essays, sermons, and excerpts from many of Lewis’s books, I trained my mind to arrive at those same conclusions with my knowledge of the Bible. Other than his sermons, all of his works did not include Bible references. I understand that his arguments were for the nonbelievers, so a logical approach is necessary because nonbelievers do not consider the Bible as a source of ultimate truth. For me to verify Lewis’s conclusions by using the Bible became my challenge.
I gave myself this challenge in order that I may train myself to approach everything with a degree of skepticism. My desire is to root myself in the Bible so that I can perceive the world in a way that pleases God. Although Lewis is known to be an extremely influential Christian thinker, I cannot take that for granted and trust everything that he says as truth. Lewis is also a human being, capable of mistakes and arriving to conclusions that may not be compatible with the Bible.
If I were to accept Lewis’s essays as truth merely because it was he who wrote them, I would be convicted of a different kind of Bulverism. Bulverism, as he defined it, “is to assume that he is wrong and then distract his attention from this” (Lewis, “Bulverism” 2). This argument could also be taken the other way, in that we cannot assume that Lewis is right because he has been correct in the past and because of his prominent role in the Christian community. His line of reasoning may be sound, but a Christian should not be completely convinced until he can determine that it follows with what the Bible has said.
I know this approach to be true because the Bible has clearly revealed this. Toward the end of the Sermon on the Mount, Jesus told his disciples, “Do not judge” (Matthew 7:1). When we go back to the Greek text, this type of judgment meant that no one was to declare a person’s morals or values as good or bad. Jesus has told us this because, if we were to form an opinion about anyone’s morals, we would judge a person’s actions depending on what we thought of his morals and because God is the only one capable of judging the heart. If you were to apply this to an extreme example, a criminal may honor his parents while a pastor may deceive his congregation.
Everything a Christian sees must be tested through the Bible, or he will be swept away by anything anyone tells him. Plantinga explained the dangers of a Christian student on a secular campus that they will not “take the time or spend the effort to sort out the good and evil in what they encounter on campus and to construct a thoughtful Christian philosophy” (Plantinga 125). I would add that it is equally dangerous for a Christian student on a Christian campus to take everything they are taught without testing it themselves. The student will suffer because he only has a secondhand faith because he has not found out these things to be actually true. C. S. Lewis warns against this type of complacency in The Screwtape Letters, saying that “As long as he retains externally the habits of a Christian he can still be made to think of himself as one… whose spiritual state is much the same as it was six weeks ago” (Lewis, “Letter XII” 1).
Christians are thus in a state of constant vigilance. Jesus told us that “If anyone would come after me, he must deny himself and take up his cross daily and follow me” (Luke 9:23). Christians desire to be more like God, and through that desire, God is able to continually transform us by the “long-term process of sanctification” (Plantinga 92). This process is not easy, for “narrow” is the road which few find (Matthew 7:14). Lewis also touched on this topic by saying that continuous pain is necessary because “however often we think we have broken the rebellious self we shall still find it alive” (Lewis, “The Problem of Pain” 89). Because we have fallen, we cannot focus on any one thing for an extended amount of time, so pain works as God’s wakeup call for His people.
Christians who continuously follow God through pain and suffering will keep learning more about His goodness and how to approach the world. Lewis made an important point that things that we continue to discover are not new. “All ideas of ‘new’ or ‘scientific’ or ‘modern’ moralities must therefore be dismissed as mere confusion of thought” (Lewis, “The Poison of Subjectivism” 3). This thought can also be applied as Christians learn about God. They continue to learn more about Him, but these things have already existed. Christians know that there are no new revelations because “in these last days he has spoken to us by his Son” (Hebrews 1:2). Jesus has spent His time on this earth as one of us, and He now lives with His Father in heaven.
Though it is impossible to learn everything about God and apply it to our lives, He is happy with our efforts. Each Christian has a calling, because they are all parts, “they form one body” (I Corinthians 12:12). Each Christian cannot learn multiple roles to follow Christ because, as Lewis quotes Hegel, “the lyf so short, the craft so long to lerne” (Lewis, “Our English Syllabus” 90). Whatever a Christian’s role may be, he will “do it all for the glory of God” (I Corinthians 10:31). Lewis explains this verse by claiming that “Christianity does not simply replace our natural life and substitute a new one” (Lewis, “Learning in War-Time” 3).
We are not to “conform any longer to the pattern of this world, but be transformed by the renewing of [our] minds” (Romans 12:2). As a Christian student, God changes the way I perceive education. It is time that I made my education my own, and not leave that decision to those who could only “bind [my] future” (Lewis, “Our English Syllabus” 93). My attitude changes from one that felt he had to learn these things in order to succeed into one that yearns after knowledge to bring glory to God and further the knowledge of that specific field.
God has placed me in this place at this time because it is according to His will and He has a purpose for me. My occupation will change as I leave Calvin, but my approach to fulfilling God’s will for my life will never change. I offer my body repeatedly to God as a living sacrifice so that He will mold me. Plantinga relates the world to a spiritual battleground and we, as students, “learn in order to throw ourselves into the battle for the kingdom of God” (Plantinga 145). The devil will rage a war on many fronts. Christians must prepare themselves because the war is upon them already. I can recognize the war just by walking down the dorm hallway. No one is excluded from this war. I have chosen sides, and I am exactly where God wants me to be. Now I have to continually search for Him to show me what to do next.
Works Cited
Holy Bible: New International Version. Biblica, 1984. Web. 25 Jan. 2010. www.biblegateway.com
Lewis, C. S. “Bulverism.” From God in the Dock. Print
Lewis, C. S. “Learning in War-Time.” Church of St. Mary the Virgin, Oxford. Lecture.
Lewis, Clive S. "Letter XII." The Screwtape Letters. Print
Lewis, C. S. “Our English Syllabus.” Oxford University Press. Print.
Lewis, C. S. “The Poison of Subjectivism”. From Christian Reflections. Print.
Plantinga, Cornelius Jr. Engaging God's Word. Grand Rapids, MI: William B. Eerdman's Publishing Co. 2002. Print
Tuesday, January 26, 2010
Sunday, January 24, 2010
The Problem of Pain
There will always be pain as long as sin exists. Plantinga called the tendency to sin against God our original sin, which is also referred to as our sin nature. We are incapable of constantly keeping our focus on the Lord because we are fallen, and the corruption blinds us to His goodness. C. S. Lewis explained that pain exists as a punishment and also a wakeup call for those who have strayed from God. Through pain, God will mold us into a vessel that He can use to further His kingdom. A Christian may want to rebel against the Lord, but he has forgotten what he has signed up for.
The man after God's own heart, David, was transformed by God before he became king. Saul plotted for his death, and he fled into the wilderness to evade Saul. God broke him down into an instrument so that he could eventually lead God's people. Pain is inevitable and necessary in order to follow God. David had done nothing wrong to deserve this, yet God made him endure many trials. A Christian may think that he is capable of serving God in his own way, but God will transform him so he can worship God in God's way. The transformation will be painful, and the only thing the Christian can control is his acceptance of the pain and his willingness to be molded by the hands of God.
It is too easy to fall "back to the toys." Is it possible for a Christian to create a situation where he is continually uncomfortable so that he will always be searching for God to supply his needs? Should Christians be striving to make their lives continuously uncomfortable so their eyes will always be on God? I have heard some pastors say to sell everything they have, give it to the poor, and live with just the bare necessities. Those pastors live out their lives that way so they can always be looking to God. They are not waiting for God to bring pain their way, but they create themselves a painful situation. God may have called them to do that or they might have done that so serve God in their own way. That is impossible to determine from my point of view.
The rich young ruler walked away from Jesus in a mood of despair because he would have to give up his status and his comfortable life style. It is hard for a rich man to pass into heaven, but I do not think a Christian should allow himself to get to that point. The Lord gives and takes away, so Christians do not gather for themselves earthly riches. Christians were not called to live comfortably but to be transformed by God into a tool for the kingdom.
The man after God's own heart, David, was transformed by God before he became king. Saul plotted for his death, and he fled into the wilderness to evade Saul. God broke him down into an instrument so that he could eventually lead God's people. Pain is inevitable and necessary in order to follow God. David had done nothing wrong to deserve this, yet God made him endure many trials. A Christian may think that he is capable of serving God in his own way, but God will transform him so he can worship God in God's way. The transformation will be painful, and the only thing the Christian can control is his acceptance of the pain and his willingness to be molded by the hands of God.
It is too easy to fall "back to the toys." Is it possible for a Christian to create a situation where he is continually uncomfortable so that he will always be searching for God to supply his needs? Should Christians be striving to make their lives continuously uncomfortable so their eyes will always be on God? I have heard some pastors say to sell everything they have, give it to the poor, and live with just the bare necessities. Those pastors live out their lives that way so they can always be looking to God. They are not waiting for God to bring pain their way, but they create themselves a painful situation. God may have called them to do that or they might have done that so serve God in their own way. That is impossible to determine from my point of view.
The rich young ruler walked away from Jesus in a mood of despair because he would have to give up his status and his comfortable life style. It is hard for a rich man to pass into heaven, but I do not think a Christian should allow himself to get to that point. The Lord gives and takes away, so Christians do not gather for themselves earthly riches. Christians were not called to live comfortably but to be transformed by God into a tool for the kingdom.
Friday, January 22, 2010
Man or Rabbit
"One of the things that distinguish man from the other animals is that he wants to know everything." A person that is content with the amount of knowledge he has is going against the natural order of things. Lewis had already explained that there had been this ultimate right and wrong known as the Moral Law. He went on to say that everyone has gone against that law because "we have failed to practice ourselves the kind of behavior we expect from other people." At least, all people should be trying to accomplish this, even if it is in their own way. I understand why Lewis would get impatient with a person who would be content with the bare minimum.
Obviously, not everyone is trying to fulfill the law. Many people will revolt against the Moral Law, and thus commit crimes against humanity or flush out their consciences by chasing meaningless pleasures. There are those who try to fulfill the law by their own merit. As Christians, we know that by our own acts, we can never be saved. Jesus told us that "I have not come to abolish them but to fulfill them" (Matthew 5:17). Jesus Christ is the only one that can fulfill the Moral Law. He works in a Christian's heart and transforms him into something more like Himself.
The weird is that Jesus does not have to do any of this, but He wants to save all of us. Because He does this out of love and compassion, Christians should show love and compassion to all that they see. They should try to further the kingdom of God with every step that they take because they know that God is the only one who can save them. Christians have to fight against this type of contentment because it creates complacency. Christians need to show them how life can be with God controlling their lives. Through their actions, nonbelievers will see a constant search for knowledge, and they will see what they are missing in their lives.
Obviously, not everyone is trying to fulfill the law. Many people will revolt against the Moral Law, and thus commit crimes against humanity or flush out their consciences by chasing meaningless pleasures. There are those who try to fulfill the law by their own merit. As Christians, we know that by our own acts, we can never be saved. Jesus told us that "I have not come to abolish them but to fulfill them" (Matthew 5:17). Jesus Christ is the only one that can fulfill the Moral Law. He works in a Christian's heart and transforms him into something more like Himself.
The weird is that Jesus does not have to do any of this, but He wants to save all of us. Because He does this out of love and compassion, Christians should show love and compassion to all that they see. They should try to further the kingdom of God with every step that they take because they know that God is the only one who can save them. Christians have to fight against this type of contentment because it creates complacency. Christians need to show them how life can be with God controlling their lives. Through their actions, nonbelievers will see a constant search for knowledge, and they will see what they are missing in their lives.
Thursday, January 21, 2010
Vocation
In the introduction of the fifth chapter, Plantinga comments that "God's kingdom has always sounded like good news for people whose lives are bad news." He will always feel better when he has hit rock bottom and starts to look up. A Christian always needs to be looking up to God and earnestly waiting his return. It is weird how a Christian may get excited about a job promotion and lose his interest in spiritual things. C. S. Lewis would call that man "an ignorant child who wants to go on making mud pies in a slum." A Christian needs to set his sights on God because that is the only thing that truly matters. Even though this may be a fairly common message, many Christians lose sight of God every day.
By having God as the center of a Christian's life, he is continually changed by the will of God which is continually rushing over him. Plantinga explained that there occurs a reformation of his occupation. His job title may not change, but his attitude and the way he communicates with coworkers will change. C. S. Lewis would agree with this point because in his sermon, Learning in War-Time, he said that "Christianity does not simply replace our natural life and substitute a new one," God is "totally present at every point of space." It is important to note that some things in a Christian's life do not need to change, but he will "be transformed by the renewing of [his] mind" (Romans 12:2). There will always be this inward transformation that brings the believer closer to God.
The Christian must always be willing to let the will of God work in their life, or he may find himself going with the flow. Plantinga commented that Christian students that attend a secular college find it difficult "to construct a thoughtful Christian philosophy of life on their own." I would add that it is also difficult for any Christian student at a Christian college to accomplish this as well. At Calvin, it can be easy to fall into a state of complacency. Even though the student may be constantly surrounded by Christian influence, he may use that as an excuse for not thinking on his own. He may be satisfied with his secondhand Christianity. It is easier to coast at Calvin than at a secular college because if you let your guard at a secular college, the results tend to be more dangerous than those that occur at Calvin. Obviously there are exceptions to this, but Calvin can easily create a situation for a Christian to take the "gentle slope" away from God (Screwtape Letters).
By having God as the center of a Christian's life, he is continually changed by the will of God which is continually rushing over him. Plantinga explained that there occurs a reformation of his occupation. His job title may not change, but his attitude and the way he communicates with coworkers will change. C. S. Lewis would agree with this point because in his sermon, Learning in War-Time, he said that "Christianity does not simply replace our natural life and substitute a new one," God is "totally present at every point of space." It is important to note that some things in a Christian's life do not need to change, but he will "be transformed by the renewing of [his] mind" (Romans 12:2). There will always be this inward transformation that brings the believer closer to God.
The Christian must always be willing to let the will of God work in their life, or he may find himself going with the flow. Plantinga commented that Christian students that attend a secular college find it difficult "to construct a thoughtful Christian philosophy of life on their own." I would add that it is also difficult for any Christian student at a Christian college to accomplish this as well. At Calvin, it can be easy to fall into a state of complacency. Even though the student may be constantly surrounded by Christian influence, he may use that as an excuse for not thinking on his own. He may be satisfied with his secondhand Christianity. It is easier to coast at Calvin than at a secular college because if you let your guard at a secular college, the results tend to be more dangerous than those that occur at Calvin. Obviously there are exceptions to this, but Calvin can easily create a situation for a Christian to take the "gentle slope" away from God (Screwtape Letters).
Wednesday, January 20, 2010
The Inner Ring
C. S. Lewis has given us his opinion on the existence of exclusive groups in his essay, The Inner Ring. Everyone has witnessed these rings and has found themselves either on the inside or the outside of the ring. Everyone has had similar thoughts to what Lewis is talking about in this essay, but not everyone has written on this topic.
An inner ring as itself is neither good nor bad, but the attitude and motives behind creating that ring decide which side the ring belongs to. For Christians, a ring needs to have a motive that furthers their walk with the Lord. Obviously, that includes the church, but that may also mean a study group that thirsts after knowledge. God may not be discussed in the study group, but the student will be able to study all he can for the glory of God. The most important group that a Christian will belong to will be the body of believers known as the church. This ring will be strongest and everlasting because it is solely held together by the power of Jesus Christ. In many of his letters, Paul will call out to his brothers in Christ. This bond takes precedence over all other bonds and will continue after death.
Just as there exists rings that are used for good, any ring that limits the Christians walk with the Lord is considered immoral. "What good is it for a man to gain the whole world, yet forfeit his soul?" (Mark 8:36) Nothing worthwhile can come from belonging to these groups, so it is better to flee from them before they take hold. This requires a change in objectives. Before he became a Christian, he might have wanted to be inside this particular ring, but if that ring can hinder his relationship with the Lord, he is taught to flee the immorality that that group represents.
Lewis explained that the "inner ring exists for exclusion." Just as there is a right and wrong motive for creating a ring, there is also the right and wrong motive for exclusion. Some groups will create exclusion for exclusion's sake while other groups create exclusion because they wish to preserve something, such as culture, religion, or a way of life. The church needs exclusion to prevent loses its purpose and identity. Many people will call themselves Christians but act no differently from a nonbeliever, thus Christianity loses its credibility.
An inner ring as itself is neither good nor bad, but the attitude and motives behind creating that ring decide which side the ring belongs to. For Christians, a ring needs to have a motive that furthers their walk with the Lord. Obviously, that includes the church, but that may also mean a study group that thirsts after knowledge. God may not be discussed in the study group, but the student will be able to study all he can for the glory of God. The most important group that a Christian will belong to will be the body of believers known as the church. This ring will be strongest and everlasting because it is solely held together by the power of Jesus Christ. In many of his letters, Paul will call out to his brothers in Christ. This bond takes precedence over all other bonds and will continue after death.
Just as there exists rings that are used for good, any ring that limits the Christians walk with the Lord is considered immoral. "What good is it for a man to gain the whole world, yet forfeit his soul?" (Mark 8:36) Nothing worthwhile can come from belonging to these groups, so it is better to flee from them before they take hold. This requires a change in objectives. Before he became a Christian, he might have wanted to be inside this particular ring, but if that ring can hinder his relationship with the Lord, he is taught to flee the immorality that that group represents.
Lewis explained that the "inner ring exists for exclusion." Just as there is a right and wrong motive for creating a ring, there is also the right and wrong motive for exclusion. Some groups will create exclusion for exclusion's sake while other groups create exclusion because they wish to preserve something, such as culture, religion, or a way of life. The church needs exclusion to prevent loses its purpose and identity. Many people will call themselves Christians but act no differently from a nonbeliever, thus Christianity loses its credibility.
The Four Loves: Eros
It it difficult to write about Eros because I have not fully experienced this type of love like some married couples have, so my argument is limited because I do not wish to talk about something that I have not experienced myself. I understand what Lewis was saying when he said that when you have this type of love, you want to be with that person in sorrow than be happy under different circumstances. I have a girlfriend, and when she was recovering from a couple extremely painful surgeries, I held her hand and watched movies with her instead of going out with friends. I do not view it as if I am limiting myself. I want to be with her even though it kills me inside to see her in pain. I cannot heal her, but I desperately try to draw her attention away from the pain.
I agree with Lewis that to love someone like this is not logical. If I were to go about this logically, I would never choose a woman because the pain of death and decay could not justify the happy times. Everything in this world is bound to change and death, causing despair and sorrow, and any man who would put logic before emotions would stay away from this type of love. The amount of sacrifice that is necessary for this love may be worth it for the man whose heart rules over his mind, but the man whose mind rules his heart would strive for self preservation and would want nothing that could weigh him down.
I would argue that emotions are necessary in Eros, but not everything in this love can be based on an emotional decision. It is a continual effort to look after her and keep her safe. You may think these strong emotions could keep going forever, but one of these days you will get tired. You may not feel like doing anything, and as a result, you may hurt the feelings of the one you want to be with forever. These days are defining moments for me. I have failed once, but I do not want to do that again. It is similar to a Christian's walk with God. One day you may feel tired and you just want to coast. These days also define his walk with God because if he just makes a decision to continue chasing after Him, these decisions will get easier because he will be closer to God, and He will wrap His arms around him.
I agree with Lewis that to love someone like this is not logical. If I were to go about this logically, I would never choose a woman because the pain of death and decay could not justify the happy times. Everything in this world is bound to change and death, causing despair and sorrow, and any man who would put logic before emotions would stay away from this type of love. The amount of sacrifice that is necessary for this love may be worth it for the man whose heart rules over his mind, but the man whose mind rules his heart would strive for self preservation and would want nothing that could weigh him down.
I would argue that emotions are necessary in Eros, but not everything in this love can be based on an emotional decision. It is a continual effort to look after her and keep her safe. You may think these strong emotions could keep going forever, but one of these days you will get tired. You may not feel like doing anything, and as a result, you may hurt the feelings of the one you want to be with forever. These days are defining moments for me. I have failed once, but I do not want to do that again. It is similar to a Christian's walk with God. One day you may feel tired and you just want to coast. These days also define his walk with God because if he just makes a decision to continue chasing after Him, these decisions will get easier because he will be closer to God, and He will wrap His arms around him.
Monday, January 18, 2010
Redemption
Plantinga attempts to explain the act of redemption to some degree in the fourth chapter of his book. He commented on how Jesus was not what the people were expecting at that time. From the Bible, I knew the people were looking for someone and the "government will on his shoulders" (Isaiah 9:6). I do not think that we will ever catch on to what God is doing in our lives until we look back on our lives. Even at the end of time, the "day of the Lord will come like a thief" (2 Peter 3:10). It will be at time that no one could have predicted. God works in mysterious ways, but we must work on how we react to God working in our lives. When God works in our lives, many times it is met with anger from those who are affected. As Christians, we need to remember God's promises or we will lose sight of what God is ultimately doing in this world. The only thing we can control is our reaction to what God is doing in our lives. We must be open to the infinite amount of ways that God could be trying to communicate to us by.
The concept that I found most interesting was when Plantinga explained that since everything has been created was originally created good, and it has all fallen, it all needs to be redeemed by God. I had never understood this concept fully, but I now have an idea of what God said through Paul in Revelation 21:5 that "I am making all things new." Everything will be redeemed because it has all fallen. I had always limited God's redemption to just souls, but God is here to redeem all of creation. The implications for stewardship are great. As Christians, we tend to think that we can only further God's kingdom by leading people to Christ, but we can also further His kingdom by being a proper steward of the world until He comes back.
The concept that I found most interesting was when Plantinga explained that since everything has been created was originally created good, and it has all fallen, it all needs to be redeemed by God. I had never understood this concept fully, but I now have an idea of what God said through Paul in Revelation 21:5 that "I am making all things new." Everything will be redeemed because it has all fallen. I had always limited God's redemption to just souls, but God is here to redeem all of creation. The implications for stewardship are great. As Christians, we tend to think that we can only further God's kingdom by leading people to Christ, but we can also further His kingdom by being a proper steward of the world until He comes back.
Learning in War-Time
In C. S. Lewis's sermon, he addressed the importance of continuing to thirst after knowledge even though a world war had enveloped the entire continent. He called for those who were not fighting to do their very best in everything they were called to do. God has not called all of us to fight for our country; He has given each of us a task. "The body is a unit, though it is made up of many parts; and though all its parts are many, they form one body." (I Corinthians 12:12) God has a different purpose for each of us because He wants to spread His light across the world. Christians would become ineffective if all had the same calling.
Lewis explained that "good philosophy exists... because bad philosophy needs to be answered." Satan fights a spiritual war on many fronts. Even though a Christian may not be fighting for his country, all Christians are called to fight in a spiritual war that will go until the end of time. Satan is not sleeping, and this spiritual war is upon all of us whether we like or not. Christians dedicate themselves whole-heartedly because they are commanded by God and so they can combat the growing evil.
One thing that a Christian must know is that there is not one final purpose for his life. The Holy Spirit is continually telling him how to follow God. One year He may be telling him to go study at a university, but the next year the Holy Spirit might be telling him to drop his studies and go serve his country. Ecclesiastes 3:1 tells us that "there is a time for everything." A Christian may think God's plan is changing, but each plan has been set in stone before he had been born.
A caution that Lewis tells us about learning is "if it becomes irresistible, he must give up his scholarly work." Lewis told us that we learn for learning's sake, but Christians also learn for God's sake as well. It is a very fine line, but as soon as the thirst for knowledge prevents you from listening to what the Holy Spirit is saying, you need to stop and readjust your sight on God. Many passages from the Bible warn us to not worship idols. This topic is not to be taken lightly because everyone falls victum to this sin at least once in their lifetime. I would put learning for God's sake as a primary reason while learning for learning's sake as a secondary reason so as to not lose sight of Him.
Lewis explained that "good philosophy exists... because bad philosophy needs to be answered." Satan fights a spiritual war on many fronts. Even though a Christian may not be fighting for his country, all Christians are called to fight in a spiritual war that will go until the end of time. Satan is not sleeping, and this spiritual war is upon all of us whether we like or not. Christians dedicate themselves whole-heartedly because they are commanded by God and so they can combat the growing evil.
One thing that a Christian must know is that there is not one final purpose for his life. The Holy Spirit is continually telling him how to follow God. One year He may be telling him to go study at a university, but the next year the Holy Spirit might be telling him to drop his studies and go serve his country. Ecclesiastes 3:1 tells us that "there is a time for everything." A Christian may think God's plan is changing, but each plan has been set in stone before he had been born.
A caution that Lewis tells us about learning is "if it becomes irresistible, he must give up his scholarly work." Lewis told us that we learn for learning's sake, but Christians also learn for God's sake as well. It is a very fine line, but as soon as the thirst for knowledge prevents you from listening to what the Holy Spirit is saying, you need to stop and readjust your sight on God. Many passages from the Bible warn us to not worship idols. This topic is not to be taken lightly because everyone falls victum to this sin at least once in their lifetime. I would put learning for God's sake as a primary reason while learning for learning's sake as a secondary reason so as to not lose sight of Him.
Saturday, January 16, 2010
The Fall
Cornelius Plantinga presented many important points in the third chapter of his book. In an explanation of one of his points, he quoted C. S. Lewis saying that the more knowledgeable a man is, "then the better it will be if it goes right, but also the worse it will be if it goes wrong." This idea of increasing accountability with knowledge came straight from the mouth of Jesus Christ. "From everyone who has been given much, much will be demanded; and from the one who has been entrusted with much, much more will be asked" (Luke 12:48). Once a man has dedicated his life to following the Lord, he is held to a higher standard than the non-believer. If a Christian and a non-believer commit the same sin, the church should punish the believer more because he should know better.
It was extremely interesting how Plantinga defined evil and sin as being a subset of evil. His explanation of how corruption occurs was intelligent, but he did not answer the question of why these things happen. I do not think we need an answer to that because if we did need that answer, God would have given it to us. I do not think we ask the right questions. While Jesus and His disciple were crossing a large body of water, a violent storm quickly came upon them, and the disciples woke Jesus up, asking Him, "Teacher, don't you care if we drown?" (Mark 4:38) Jesus did not answer their question, but He rebuked them of having little faith. As we look at tragedies, we ask God how could He have let this happen, but Christians should be asking Him about what He is trying to teach them.
Christians do not need to know why God allows these things to happen because they "know that in all things God works for the good of those who love him" (Romans 8:28). This type of good is not talking about physical health, but for the good of a Christian's walk with God. By strengthening a Christian's relationship with Himself, He ultimately brings more glory to Himself and furthers His kingdom. Many Christians will forget to focus on God when tragedy strikes, but they must remember that it is not about them because they are not their own (I Corinthians 6:19).
It was extremely interesting how Plantinga defined evil and sin as being a subset of evil. His explanation of how corruption occurs was intelligent, but he did not answer the question of why these things happen. I do not think we need an answer to that because if we did need that answer, God would have given it to us. I do not think we ask the right questions. While Jesus and His disciple were crossing a large body of water, a violent storm quickly came upon them, and the disciples woke Jesus up, asking Him, "Teacher, don't you care if we drown?" (Mark 4:38) Jesus did not answer their question, but He rebuked them of having little faith. As we look at tragedies, we ask God how could He have let this happen, but Christians should be asking Him about what He is trying to teach them.
Christians do not need to know why God allows these things to happen because they "know that in all things God works for the good of those who love him" (Romans 8:28). This type of good is not talking about physical health, but for the good of a Christian's walk with God. By strengthening a Christian's relationship with Himself, He ultimately brings more glory to Himself and furthers His kingdom. Many Christians will forget to focus on God when tragedy strikes, but they must remember that it is not about them because they are not their own (I Corinthians 6:19).
The Poison of Subjectivism
I thought it was extremely interesting how he was able to make such an outrageous claim that there were no new ideologies or new sets of moralities. Everything that has been claimed to be new has come from past ideologies that have been reworded and have parts that have been emphasized or omitted. After a closer look, this claim has major roots embedded in solid biblical references.
Besides the six days of creation and a few miracles performed by Jesus Christ, nothing new has been made. As it has been written, "without him nothing was made that has been made" (John 1:3). Everything that was needed for us has already been made, and God created it all. This goes for ideas as well as physical objects. I think Solomon said it best that "there is nothing new under the sun" (Ecclesiastes 1:9). The wisest man who ever lived recognized that he could not create anything but to use what he has been given by God.
In this world, everything that has been called new has been merely a different perspective on something that already existed. Christians should guard themselves against any new ideologies. From Hebrews 1:1-2, we know that God use to speak to the people through prophets and other ways, but everything that was needed to be said was "spoken to us by his Son." Since the Holy Bible is the Word of God, everything that a Christian would need to know about being a Christian is in that book. God does not need to talk to us anymore because it is all in the Bible. He may want to tell us things individually that we have forgotten, but that is another topic.
The Bible also tells Christians how to look at the world, and by doing so, they avoid the temptation of falling into subjectivism. Paul tells Christians that "we live by faith, not by sight" (II Corinthians 5:7). Christians strive to listen to what the Holy Spirit is telling them instead of looking at the world through their own logic and reasoning. A Christian may have a solid Christian worldview, but he needs to constantly be trying to serve God in any way to avoid complacency, where sin creeps in and corrupts.
Besides the six days of creation and a few miracles performed by Jesus Christ, nothing new has been made. As it has been written, "without him nothing was made that has been made" (John 1:3). Everything that was needed for us has already been made, and God created it all. This goes for ideas as well as physical objects. I think Solomon said it best that "there is nothing new under the sun" (Ecclesiastes 1:9). The wisest man who ever lived recognized that he could not create anything but to use what he has been given by God.
In this world, everything that has been called new has been merely a different perspective on something that already existed. Christians should guard themselves against any new ideologies. From Hebrews 1:1-2, we know that God use to speak to the people through prophets and other ways, but everything that was needed to be said was "spoken to us by his Son." Since the Holy Bible is the Word of God, everything that a Christian would need to know about being a Christian is in that book. God does not need to talk to us anymore because it is all in the Bible. He may want to tell us things individually that we have forgotten, but that is another topic.
The Bible also tells Christians how to look at the world, and by doing so, they avoid the temptation of falling into subjectivism. Paul tells Christians that "we live by faith, not by sight" (II Corinthians 5:7). Christians strive to listen to what the Holy Spirit is telling them instead of looking at the world through their own logic and reasoning. A Christian may have a solid Christian worldview, but he needs to constantly be trying to serve God in any way to avoid complacency, where sin creeps in and corrupts.
Thursday, January 14, 2010
Mere Christianity
From the first chapters of Mere Christianity, C. S. Lewis presents the argument that the existence of a true right and wrong point to a power that is outside of the universe that has created the Law of Nature. His argument provided extremely solid logic that rests on few presuppositions. I really enjoyed how this argument could be used in real life situation to be able to witness to someone.
We know this argument is true because we hold what the Bible says as true. In Romans 2:12-16, Paul states that all men are without excuse because "they show that the work of the law is written on their hearts." Everyone has been born with, what we call, the Moral Law. This could also be referred to as your conscience. What people decide to do when they feel the Moral Law calling is a different story. Some people ignore it, trying to run from it into a sense of depravity. Lewis notes that everyone has failed "to practise ourselves the kind of behaviour we expect from other people." Christians strive to follow God and to love others because they are commanded. They also have the Holy Spirit to guide them in the way they are to act. The Holy Spirit will help them not by keeping them away from what they should not be doing but by showing them opportunities to serve God.
The picture that I enjoyed the most was the analogy of the piano. Lewis stated that all impulses are neither good nor bad, but the Moral Law tells us when to act on each impulse or instinct. I just started to play the piano again a few weeks ago, and one thing that I know is that I need a lot of practice to get back to where I was and to play the music correctly. Many times it will be easy to quit, but to continue practicing shows dedication that will separate someone from the rest of the crowd. A Christian should be willing to follow that Moral Law even when it may be an act of sacrifice. That determination will set him apart from the crowd, and in him, they will notice Christ.
We know this argument is true because we hold what the Bible says as true. In Romans 2:12-16, Paul states that all men are without excuse because "they show that the work of the law is written on their hearts." Everyone has been born with, what we call, the Moral Law. This could also be referred to as your conscience. What people decide to do when they feel the Moral Law calling is a different story. Some people ignore it, trying to run from it into a sense of depravity. Lewis notes that everyone has failed "to practise ourselves the kind of behaviour we expect from other people." Christians strive to follow God and to love others because they are commanded. They also have the Holy Spirit to guide them in the way they are to act. The Holy Spirit will help them not by keeping them away from what they should not be doing but by showing them opportunities to serve God.
The picture that I enjoyed the most was the analogy of the piano. Lewis stated that all impulses are neither good nor bad, but the Moral Law tells us when to act on each impulse or instinct. I just started to play the piano again a few weeks ago, and one thing that I know is that I need a lot of practice to get back to where I was and to play the music correctly. Many times it will be easy to quit, but to continue practicing shows dedication that will separate someone from the rest of the crowd. A Christian should be willing to follow that Moral Law even when it may be an act of sacrifice. That determination will set him apart from the crowd, and in him, they will notice Christ.
An Inconvenient Truth
After watching An Inconvenient Truth, I thought of a couple important things that are worth discussing, but one point must be made first. This movie, as most people know, was made by the politician, Al Gore, so all information presented has multiple motives behind it and all should be viewed with a degree of speculation. I say this not because I am Republican, I do not find my place with any one party; I say this because he, just like all people, is capable of lying and manipulating other people. A point that I will make in this blog relies on what Al Gore has said as statements that have varying degrees of truth to it.
As Al Gore was speaking to the crowd during one of his slide show talks, he commented how we should not ignore the scientific experts on their findings. I am paraphrasing this, but I think this was one of the points he was trying to get across to his audience. This made me remember the prophets and how they pleaded with Israel and Judah to reset their sights on God or be scattered throughout the surrounding nations. This connection may be very rough, but these scientific experts symbolize the prophets. Although God does not talk directly to us now like He talked to the prophets, He has already said everything that needs to be said in the Bible and through nature, which is a general revelation. I wanted to pose a question with this paragraph: If there was truth in what Al Gore had said, and we continue on a path that ignores those experts, will the world reap a consequence of similar degree that the Israelites suffered? I think we will because I know it from Revelations. God may be using those scientists to communicate to the world a calling to become the good stewards that we should have been a long time ago.
Another connection that I wish to draw is between a couple scenes in this movie and with C. S. Lewis's essay, Bulverism. There were multiple clips that insulted Gore. One man called Gore's plead as a "hoax" while George W. Bush said Gore was "crazy." These clips may have been taken out of context and the real reason why these clips might have been included was to evoke an emotional response, but these are prime examples of Bulverism. It's far easier to argue the man than to argue with actual facts, because that takes time and effort. Republicans make Democrats the enemy and vice versa because they want to win, even though both have elements of truth. As to which one has more truth, I cannot say, because I do not know.
As Al Gore was speaking to the crowd during one of his slide show talks, he commented how we should not ignore the scientific experts on their findings. I am paraphrasing this, but I think this was one of the points he was trying to get across to his audience. This made me remember the prophets and how they pleaded with Israel and Judah to reset their sights on God or be scattered throughout the surrounding nations. This connection may be very rough, but these scientific experts symbolize the prophets. Although God does not talk directly to us now like He talked to the prophets, He has already said everything that needs to be said in the Bible and through nature, which is a general revelation. I wanted to pose a question with this paragraph: If there was truth in what Al Gore had said, and we continue on a path that ignores those experts, will the world reap a consequence of similar degree that the Israelites suffered? I think we will because I know it from Revelations. God may be using those scientists to communicate to the world a calling to become the good stewards that we should have been a long time ago.
Another connection that I wish to draw is between a couple scenes in this movie and with C. S. Lewis's essay, Bulverism. There were multiple clips that insulted Gore. One man called Gore's plead as a "hoax" while George W. Bush said Gore was "crazy." These clips may have been taken out of context and the real reason why these clips might have been included was to evoke an emotional response, but these are prime examples of Bulverism. It's far easier to argue the man than to argue with actual facts, because that takes time and effort. Republicans make Democrats the enemy and vice versa because they want to win, even though both have elements of truth. As to which one has more truth, I cannot say, because I do not know.
Wednesday, January 13, 2010
Screwtape Letters
As I was reading the selected passages from Screwtape Letters, by C. S. Lewis, one concept that intrigued me was the slow separation of a Christian from God. Even though the battle for the Christian's soul has been decided, the devil will continue to ruin him by separating him from God in order to render him ineffective of furthering the kingdom of God. Matthew 5:13 poses the question, "if the salt loses its saltiness, how can it be made salty again?" The passage goes on to say that it has no purpose and will be "trampled by man." It is still important to note that it is still salt, or Christian, so he will still go to heaven. That man's testimony has been shattered, but he still has the possibility of running back to God and giving Him all that he has. There will be consequences, but he will have the opportunity to further God's kingdom once again.
There are many verses that warn against complacency and command constant diligence, but one verse that most appeals to me is Luke 9:43. "If anyone would come after me, he must deny himself and take up his cross daily and follow me." Many Christians think they are satisfying their spiritual obligation by attending church for a couple hours out of each week, but this verse is talking about the 168 hours of each week. Christians should be continuously searching, continuously serving. They must either strive for God or be lulled into complacency where sin is waiting and scheming to take hold of their lives.
Just as it is a slow process to take away a Christian's testimony, it can also be a slow and difficult process to follow God. To follow God is to find the narrow path that few find, and the one yearning after God runs the good race until he is joined with the Father in heaven (Matthew 7:14, Galatians 5:7). Either we are in a storm or a storm is coming. The only we hope we could possibly have is in the rock of salvation, or else we could we swept away with the storm into the abyss that even fewer escape. Christians keep watch, because they do not know when the Lord is coming, just as they do not know when the thief will come to steal in the night (Matthew 24:42-43).
There are many verses that warn against complacency and command constant diligence, but one verse that most appeals to me is Luke 9:43. "If anyone would come after me, he must deny himself and take up his cross daily and follow me." Many Christians think they are satisfying their spiritual obligation by attending church for a couple hours out of each week, but this verse is talking about the 168 hours of each week. Christians should be continuously searching, continuously serving. They must either strive for God or be lulled into complacency where sin is waiting and scheming to take hold of their lives.
Just as it is a slow process to take away a Christian's testimony, it can also be a slow and difficult process to follow God. To follow God is to find the narrow path that few find, and the one yearning after God runs the good race until he is joined with the Father in heaven (Matthew 7:14, Galatians 5:7). Either we are in a storm or a storm is coming. The only we hope we could possibly have is in the rock of salvation, or else we could we swept away with the storm into the abyss that even fewer escape. Christians keep watch, because they do not know when the Lord is coming, just as they do not know when the thief will come to steal in the night (Matthew 24:42-43).
Creation
The topic that I found most interesting in the second chapter of Plantinga's book was that we are commanded to be like God because we were made by him. We have been given purpose through our creation. Because God knew each and every one of us before we were born, He already loves us and has given each of us a purpose. Through His eternal love that continuously pours out over all people, we are to reciprocate that love back to Him and to everyone around us. Our purpose is to desire to be Christ-like because God loved us first. I think Plantinga quotes a very powerful statement that "a thing created is loved before it exists."
The rest of this chapter explains certain aspects of God and how we are to follow that. One aspect that I think most people are starting to be more aware of is the need for stewardship of the planet. It is true that there have been exaggerations of how bad of a condition the earth is in right now, but they are right that the state of the earth is on a negative slope. There are those who make fun of the tree huggers, but they are blind to the fact that those tree huggers are picking up the slack that those scoffers are not carrying. I think there needs to be more talk of preserving the earth in the Christian community because it is a relevant topic that affects us all.
Another aspect that Plantinga brought up was the self sufficiency of the trinity. Plantinga called it the "endless dance and perichoresis." Just as the trinity supports each other, the church should lift each other up. Paul had heard of love of the church in Colosse for God and each other. I have seen Christians get into angry arguments over doctrine, and I have seen Christians that were thrown out of their Christian social groups. Christianity has been given a bad name by these people. If Christians cannot love each other, how are they supposed to genuinely love a nonbeliever?
The rest of this chapter explains certain aspects of God and how we are to follow that. One aspect that I think most people are starting to be more aware of is the need for stewardship of the planet. It is true that there have been exaggerations of how bad of a condition the earth is in right now, but they are right that the state of the earth is on a negative slope. There are those who make fun of the tree huggers, but they are blind to the fact that those tree huggers are picking up the slack that those scoffers are not carrying. I think there needs to be more talk of preserving the earth in the Christian community because it is a relevant topic that affects us all.
Another aspect that Plantinga brought up was the self sufficiency of the trinity. Plantinga called it the "endless dance and perichoresis." Just as the trinity supports each other, the church should lift each other up. Paul had heard of love of the church in Colosse for God and each other. I have seen Christians get into angry arguments over doctrine, and I have seen Christians that were thrown out of their Christian social groups. Christianity has been given a bad name by these people. If Christians cannot love each other, how are they supposed to genuinely love a nonbeliever?
Tuesday, January 12, 2010
The Weight of Glory
In the beginning of this essay, Lewis explains the difference between a mercenary reward and a proper or natural reward. I think Lewis's point was the importance of clarifying proper motives that act in accordance with God. Many people will go into a project with the wrong motives; they may work just as hard as the man who has the proper motives, but he will not be satisfied with what he gained. Only the man who has proper motives will be satisfied with his work and will breathe in deep God's peace. A man with mercenary motive will reap more greed and will forever chase after the peace of the other man.
I enjoyed how Lewis drew up the example of how a student who had just started to study Greek could not look forward to the "enjoyment of Sophocles" and how there is a progression by "working for marks." This picture reminds me of how Jesus would compare faith to a mustard seed and how that would grow into one of the largest trees of the forest. There are many similarities between the examples Lewis has given and faith, but I believe that there is a large disconnect between them.
All the rewards that Lewis had been talking about in the beginning of the essay have been rewards that we have the potential of experiencing in this life. The reward that Christians experience after this life cannot be attained purely through human effort. Salvation for a sinner who has confessed is not a proper reward. The math just does not add up. A Christian will receive much more than he has given when we are before Him. God chooses to give Christians this reward purely out of love and grace.
When Christians are before the Lord, He will say "Well done, thou good and faithful servant." They are ants in His presence, but He chooses to acknowledge them and lift them up. They will fall to the ground because they are trembling with indescribable joy. They will be humbled because they know that they could never do enough on their own to receive God's grace. That is the weight of glory.
I enjoyed how Lewis drew up the example of how a student who had just started to study Greek could not look forward to the "enjoyment of Sophocles" and how there is a progression by "working for marks." This picture reminds me of how Jesus would compare faith to a mustard seed and how that would grow into one of the largest trees of the forest. There are many similarities between the examples Lewis has given and faith, but I believe that there is a large disconnect between them.
All the rewards that Lewis had been talking about in the beginning of the essay have been rewards that we have the potential of experiencing in this life. The reward that Christians experience after this life cannot be attained purely through human effort. Salvation for a sinner who has confessed is not a proper reward. The math just does not add up. A Christian will receive much more than he has given when we are before Him. God chooses to give Christians this reward purely out of love and grace.
When Christians are before the Lord, He will say "Well done, thou good and faithful servant." They are ants in His presence, but He chooses to acknowledge them and lift them up. They will fall to the ground because they are trembling with indescribable joy. They will be humbled because they know that they could never do enough on their own to receive God's grace. That is the weight of glory.
Monday, January 11, 2010
Our English Syllabus
I understand the argument that C. S. Lewis was trying to make in his essay, Our English Syllabus, but I believe that he is lacking an important component to his essay. Lewis fails to denote why we "thirst for knowledge." I completely agree that there is a balance between education and learning, and when we are at college, we should have a mindset of yearning after knowledge instead of dragging our feet and doing the bare minimum. The only question I have for Lewis concerns our purpose for learning. I understand that we must make a living in this world, but we are not machines; there must be a higher purpose for longing after knowledge.
There was a point brought up in class that Lewis did not intend for the supernatural to be included in the argument, but I believe that some of the Oxford students that this essay was addressed to would not be satisfied by Lewis's incomplete argument. Receiving an education will not validate their lives. Even if they were to have their leisure time, it would not validate their existence.
To approach this from a Christian perspective, an important distinction is that Christians find their identity in Christ and not in their knowledge or work. Lewis gave us general example of people that thirst after knowledge, but a Christian should first be thirsting after God and listening to what the Holy Spirit is saying to them. If it is in God's plan that you should go to college or chase after knowledge, then you should do it with everything God has given you because you are serving God through it. It may be in His plan that you should not receive an education and stay home to look after your parents who need constant care. The situation may not be as drastic as that example, but it may be as simple as you wanting to study biology while God wants you to study psychology. God knows you better than yourself, and He has a reason for doing everything that He does.
If God has called you to have an education, you should put everything you have into achieving that goal. In this essay, Lewis wants the students to "follow learning for its own sake," but a Christian should receive an education in order to follow God's command and so that they can further the kingdom of God. A balance of specified and general education is needed in order to witness to a variety of people types. In I Corinthians 9:22, Paul told the Corinthians that "I have become all things to all men so that by all possible means I might save some." The only reason Christians desire an education is so they can further the kingdom, not for personal gain or to further learning.
There was a point brought up in class that Lewis did not intend for the supernatural to be included in the argument, but I believe that some of the Oxford students that this essay was addressed to would not be satisfied by Lewis's incomplete argument. Receiving an education will not validate their lives. Even if they were to have their leisure time, it would not validate their existence.
To approach this from a Christian perspective, an important distinction is that Christians find their identity in Christ and not in their knowledge or work. Lewis gave us general example of people that thirst after knowledge, but a Christian should first be thirsting after God and listening to what the Holy Spirit is saying to them. If it is in God's plan that you should go to college or chase after knowledge, then you should do it with everything God has given you because you are serving God through it. It may be in His plan that you should not receive an education and stay home to look after your parents who need constant care. The situation may not be as drastic as that example, but it may be as simple as you wanting to study biology while God wants you to study psychology. God knows you better than yourself, and He has a reason for doing everything that He does.
If God has called you to have an education, you should put everything you have into achieving that goal. In this essay, Lewis wants the students to "follow learning for its own sake," but a Christian should receive an education in order to follow God's command and so that they can further the kingdom of God. A balance of specified and general education is needed in order to witness to a variety of people types. In I Corinthians 9:22, Paul told the Corinthians that "I have become all things to all men so that by all possible means I might save some." The only reason Christians desire an education is so they can further the kingdom, not for personal gain or to further learning.
Saturday, January 9, 2010
Longing and Hope
Throughout the first chapter of Engaging God's World, by Cornelius Plantinga Jr., he explains the phenomena of yearning and how that affects a person's hopes. During his explanation, he references C. S. Lewis, summarizing Lewis's point that all people are full of longings "that point us beyond the things of earth to the ultimate reality of God."
As I meditated on this statement, I began to see what Lewis was meaning. Everything that man has long for, besides God, has left man with a feeling of emptiness and an insatiable appetite for more. Everything on this earth will fade away, just as it had been said in Matthew 6:19, a warning against storing "treasures on earth, where moth and dust destroy." While everything will fade away, God will always remain, pure and constant. God is my ultimate longing because He has told us himself that He is the "bread of life" (John 6:35) and the water of life (John 4:13-14). In a logical approach, it would be better to pursue God, who will never leave you and will not cause you to want anything ever again.
I love how Plantinga ended the chapter by explaining how hope progresses from hoping for just ourselves to hoping for others. As a Christian, we should wish that everyone can experience God in some way, and we should do everything to show the love that God has given us. I like how Plantinga defined shalom as "universal flourishing, wholeness, and delight," and how we all hope for that to happen. Some people will experience confined moments of shalom while the vast majority will go throughout their entire lives without it. Plantinga makes this comment even more depressing by commenting that shalom "is the way things are supposed to be."
I think that we can never fully experience the fullest of what shalom actually means. People may witness moments of shalom, but they are just moments and are localized. The people would not be able to fully comprehend what had actually taken place because of the brevity of the moment and because they do not have the focus capacity to understand because of the sin in their lives. Shalom will not have attained its full meaning and depth on this earth until God comes back to set up his kingdom. We, as Christians, hope in this promise because it will come to pass and it will be greater than anything we could ever imagine.
As I meditated on this statement, I began to see what Lewis was meaning. Everything that man has long for, besides God, has left man with a feeling of emptiness and an insatiable appetite for more. Everything on this earth will fade away, just as it had been said in Matthew 6:19, a warning against storing "treasures on earth, where moth and dust destroy." While everything will fade away, God will always remain, pure and constant. God is my ultimate longing because He has told us himself that He is the "bread of life" (John 6:35) and the water of life (John 4:13-14). In a logical approach, it would be better to pursue God, who will never leave you and will not cause you to want anything ever again.
I love how Plantinga ended the chapter by explaining how hope progresses from hoping for just ourselves to hoping for others. As a Christian, we should wish that everyone can experience God in some way, and we should do everything to show the love that God has given us. I like how Plantinga defined shalom as "universal flourishing, wholeness, and delight," and how we all hope for that to happen. Some people will experience confined moments of shalom while the vast majority will go throughout their entire lives without it. Plantinga makes this comment even more depressing by commenting that shalom "is the way things are supposed to be."
I think that we can never fully experience the fullest of what shalom actually means. People may witness moments of shalom, but they are just moments and are localized. The people would not be able to fully comprehend what had actually taken place because of the brevity of the moment and because they do not have the focus capacity to understand because of the sin in their lives. Shalom will not have attained its full meaning and depth on this earth until God comes back to set up his kingdom. We, as Christians, hope in this promise because it will come to pass and it will be greater than anything we could ever imagine.
Friday, January 8, 2010
A Right to Happiness
After reading C. S. Lewis' essay on the right to happiness, I think that people do not have a right to happiness. From Romans 3:23 and 6:23, we know that all have sinned and the wages of sin is death. The only thing we deserve is death and hell. God, through His mercy, took upon himself what we deserved. Through His grace, God provided us with everything that we have and an opportunity to be with Him one day. God gave us the capability of experiencing happiness and joy even though we have no right, which perpetuates even more joy and thankfulness. Christians find their joy in God and what He has given to us.
Now there is an importance to identify the difference between happiness and joy. Joy can only come from God to those who are desperately seeking Him and worshipping Him with everything they have. Happiness can come from anywhere, causing people with a distorted perception of life to chase sinful sources for shallow, instant gratification. Joy is more worthwhile than happiness because it lasts, and you are doing what God has commanded you to do. Happiness could come from an innocent source and not be considered a sin, but it will not last.
A Christian should want only what God's will is, and they will be filled with joy, even in their suffering because it furthers the kingdom. When you become a Christian, you forfeit everything to God. It ceases to become about you and your time. When Mr. A divorces Mrs. A to marry Mrs. B, Mr. A has lost sight of what God has called him to do and has become selfish. His duty was to his wife, but he has lost that perspective and thinks that he could achieve real happiness with his next wife.
A good point that I think Lewis made was when we make an exception for a "sexual impulse," it has the possibility to "seep through our whole lives." Human beings will continue to push the limits, creating more exceptions until the rules are tossed. It chills me to think that society is on a pathway to self destruction. I do not think it will end until He comes back.
Now there is an importance to identify the difference between happiness and joy. Joy can only come from God to those who are desperately seeking Him and worshipping Him with everything they have. Happiness can come from anywhere, causing people with a distorted perception of life to chase sinful sources for shallow, instant gratification. Joy is more worthwhile than happiness because it lasts, and you are doing what God has commanded you to do. Happiness could come from an innocent source and not be considered a sin, but it will not last.
A Christian should want only what God's will is, and they will be filled with joy, even in their suffering because it furthers the kingdom. When you become a Christian, you forfeit everything to God. It ceases to become about you and your time. When Mr. A divorces Mrs. A to marry Mrs. B, Mr. A has lost sight of what God has called him to do and has become selfish. His duty was to his wife, but he has lost that perspective and thinks that he could achieve real happiness with his next wife.
A good point that I think Lewis made was when we make an exception for a "sexual impulse," it has the possibility to "seep through our whole lives." Human beings will continue to push the limits, creating more exceptions until the rules are tossed. It chills me to think that society is on a pathway to self destruction. I do not think it will end until He comes back.
Thursday, January 7, 2010
Bulverism
As I was reading C. S. Lewis' essay on Bulverism, one thing that stood out to me was the lack of legitimate reasons in arguments. I had not really thought about that before, but as I remember past arguments, I rarely remember any valid reasons being used. There have been arguments that I've heard that included superb reasoning but the vast majority have not even discussed that actual issue. Especially in politics, debates tend to argue the qualifications of the candidates instead of focusing on the issue that was questioned. As Lewis put it, people tend to argue with causes instead of reasons.
I liked how Lewis applied reason to Bulverism by saying Bulverism tries to prove that all proofs are invalid, which should in itself be a proof, making Bulverism self-defeating. Another fallacy I think Bulverism is convicted of is called the "poisoning the well" fallacy, which means that if you malign the person making the claim, then his claim is false. While both of these arguments discredit the validity of Bulverism, they fail to point toward the real reason why people take this view in the first place.
I think Bulverism is just complicated way of being ignorant. It is just a childish response when the individual is confronted with an argument. Bulverists have confined themselves to viewing things in only one perspective, denying otherwise apparant truth from other points of view. They close themselves off to reason and growth in understanding and wisdom. Bulverism is the easiest response to any confrontation, making it a response people usually see, but it extremely limits the potential of the individual.
Coming from a Christian worldview, I would call Bulverism a lack of humility. Bulverists close themselves off to other sources that could be trying to show them what God wants for their lives. These sources often appear in places that the individual would not expect, but the Bulverists mindset would automatically shut out these sources. They miss out on God's joy and create a cycle of easy choices that becomes a vicious habit. They will also miss out on applicable truth that will help them grow in their relationship will the Lord.
C. S. Lewis creates a solid argument against Bulverism using logical reasoning instead of approaching from a Biblical standpoint. This intrigued me, but I understand this argument was intended for an audience including non-Christians, making sense that he would use a non-Biblical approach.
I liked how Lewis applied reason to Bulverism by saying Bulverism tries to prove that all proofs are invalid, which should in itself be a proof, making Bulverism self-defeating. Another fallacy I think Bulverism is convicted of is called the "poisoning the well" fallacy, which means that if you malign the person making the claim, then his claim is false. While both of these arguments discredit the validity of Bulverism, they fail to point toward the real reason why people take this view in the first place.
I think Bulverism is just complicated way of being ignorant. It is just a childish response when the individual is confronted with an argument. Bulverists have confined themselves to viewing things in only one perspective, denying otherwise apparant truth from other points of view. They close themselves off to reason and growth in understanding and wisdom. Bulverism is the easiest response to any confrontation, making it a response people usually see, but it extremely limits the potential of the individual.
Coming from a Christian worldview, I would call Bulverism a lack of humility. Bulverists close themselves off to other sources that could be trying to show them what God wants for their lives. These sources often appear in places that the individual would not expect, but the Bulverists mindset would automatically shut out these sources. They miss out on God's joy and create a cycle of easy choices that becomes a vicious habit. They will also miss out on applicable truth that will help them grow in their relationship will the Lord.
C. S. Lewis creates a solid argument against Bulverism using logical reasoning instead of approaching from a Biblical standpoint. This intrigued me, but I understand this argument was intended for an audience including non-Christians, making sense that he would use a non-Biblical approach.
Meditation in a Toolshed
In C. S. Lewis' essay, "Meditation in a Toolshed," he repeatedly expresses the need for people to approach a situation by looking along it in an emotionally connecting way. Through multiple examples, Lewis recognized a pattern that when a person looks at a situation, he dehumanizes and objectifies the situation. I think Lewis makes this distinction because he saw how people in the modern world viewed everything through a scientific lens. His call was that people need to approach from different points of view to avoid narrow-mindedness and deception.
Because each point of view has pros and cons, multiple views are needed to recover all relevant information and so a person can accurately make their own stance on the situation. By looking along, a person could easily connect and understand the situation from the inside, but with growing sympathy, the person may feel the pain and hardship of the situation or he may be persuaded to think a certain way that goes against his presuppositions. When he looks at a situation, he is able to view the bigger picture of things, but he disregards the emotions of the situation. both views are necessary in order to search for truth that could be applicable to a person's life.
The order of the views is not important, but how a person approaches each view is important. Lewis wrote that "we must start with no prejudice for or against either kind of looking." When a person changes his view, he cannot let his past conclusions from the previous view influence the conclusions of the next. To keep conclusions separate encourages open-mindedness. I think this is crucial on an individual level because the person will develop important skills in discernment.
I agree with Lewis that people have developed a pattern of narrow-mindedness and that to look from multiple perspectives encourages discernment and the search for truth.
Because each point of view has pros and cons, multiple views are needed to recover all relevant information and so a person can accurately make their own stance on the situation. By looking along, a person could easily connect and understand the situation from the inside, but with growing sympathy, the person may feel the pain and hardship of the situation or he may be persuaded to think a certain way that goes against his presuppositions. When he looks at a situation, he is able to view the bigger picture of things, but he disregards the emotions of the situation. both views are necessary in order to search for truth that could be applicable to a person's life.
The order of the views is not important, but how a person approaches each view is important. Lewis wrote that "we must start with no prejudice for or against either kind of looking." When a person changes his view, he cannot let his past conclusions from the previous view influence the conclusions of the next. To keep conclusions separate encourages open-mindedness. I think this is crucial on an individual level because the person will develop important skills in discernment.
I agree with Lewis that people have developed a pattern of narrow-mindedness and that to look from multiple perspectives encourages discernment and the search for truth.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)