Thursday, January 7, 2010

Bulverism

As I was reading C. S. Lewis' essay on Bulverism, one thing that stood out to me was the lack of legitimate reasons in arguments. I had not really thought about that before, but as I remember past arguments, I rarely remember any valid reasons being used. There have been arguments that I've heard that included superb reasoning but the vast majority have not even discussed that actual issue. Especially in politics, debates tend to argue the qualifications of the candidates instead of focusing on the issue that was questioned. As Lewis put it, people tend to argue with causes instead of reasons.

I liked how Lewis applied reason to Bulverism by saying Bulverism tries to prove that all proofs are invalid, which should in itself be a proof, making Bulverism self-defeating. Another fallacy I think Bulverism is convicted of is called the "poisoning the well" fallacy, which means that if you malign the person making the claim, then his claim is false. While both of these arguments discredit the validity of Bulverism, they fail to point toward the real reason why people take this view in the first place.

I think Bulverism is just complicated way of being ignorant. It is just a childish response when the individual is confronted with an argument. Bulverists have confined themselves to viewing things in only one perspective, denying otherwise apparant truth from other points of view. They close themselves off to reason and growth in understanding and wisdom. Bulverism is the easiest response to any confrontation, making it a response people usually see, but it extremely limits the potential of the individual.

Coming from a Christian worldview, I would call Bulverism a lack of humility. Bulverists close themselves off to other sources that could be trying to show them what God wants for their lives. These sources often appear in places that the individual would not expect, but the Bulverists mindset would automatically shut out these sources. They miss out on God's joy and create a cycle of easy choices that becomes a vicious habit. They will also miss out on applicable truth that will help them grow in their relationship will the Lord.

C. S. Lewis creates a solid argument against Bulverism using logical reasoning instead of approaching from a Biblical standpoint. This intrigued me, but I understand this argument was intended for an audience including non-Christians, making sense that he would use a non-Biblical approach.

2 comments:

  1. I appreciate that you had a paragraph on the Christian perspective; I admit I didn't even think of it.

    I do think, perhaps, that Bulverism is more popularly successful when both sides are using the same tactics. After all, while sometimes we're definitely astounded by the stupidity of the human race, it isn't often that a solid, logical argument wouldn't win against a Bulverist attempt to discredit it.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think your opinion that Bulverism is the simple and even childish way out of an argument is one that must be duly noted.

    Bulversim is in essence an attack on our very own intellect because we are trying to prove, as Lewis says "that all proofs are invalid." Therefore one ends up only making themself look silly because that same argument could be used to counter it.

    Nice writing :)

    ReplyDelete