Monday, January 11, 2010

Our English Syllabus

I understand the argument that C. S. Lewis was trying to make in his essay, Our English Syllabus, but I believe that he is lacking an important component to his essay. Lewis fails to denote why we "thirst for knowledge." I completely agree that there is a balance between education and learning, and when we are at college, we should have a mindset of yearning after knowledge instead of dragging our feet and doing the bare minimum. The only question I have for Lewis concerns our purpose for learning. I understand that we must make a living in this world, but we are not machines; there must be a higher purpose for longing after knowledge.

There was a point brought up in class that Lewis did not intend for the supernatural to be included in the argument, but I believe that some of the Oxford students that this essay was addressed to would not be satisfied by Lewis's incomplete argument. Receiving an education will not validate their lives. Even if they were to have their leisure time, it would not validate their existence.

To approach this from a Christian perspective, an important distinction is that Christians find their identity in Christ and not in their knowledge or work. Lewis gave us general example of people that thirst after knowledge, but a Christian should first be thirsting after God and listening to what the Holy Spirit is saying to them. If it is in God's plan that you should go to college or chase after knowledge, then you should do it with everything God has given you because you are serving God through it. It may be in His plan that you should not receive an education and stay home to look after your parents who need constant care. The situation may not be as drastic as that example, but it may be as simple as you wanting to study biology while God wants you to study psychology. God knows you better than yourself, and He has a reason for doing everything that He does.

If God has called you to have an education, you should put everything you have into achieving that goal. In this essay, Lewis wants the students to "follow learning for its own sake," but a Christian should receive an education in order to follow God's command and so that they can further the kingdom of God. A balance of specified and general education is needed in order to witness to a variety of people types. In I Corinthians 9:22, Paul told the Corinthians that "I have become all things to all men so that by all possible means I might save some." The only reason Christians desire an education is so they can further the kingdom, not for personal gain or to further learning.

2 comments:

  1. I thought your questioning of Lewis' argument, or at least bring up the need for clarification of a intrical partof his argument. However, I think his point is still understood regardless. Also, I like the connection you made between the Christian life and education.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Sam,

    I like the quotation you take from 1 Corinthians. Learning about various subjects gives us the ability to connect with others, thereby allowing us to share the Gospel. However, don't you think learning for the sake of learning about God's world is also important? In my opinion, the more we examine God's world, the more we can understand how amazing he is.

    ReplyDelete